Indiana Criminal Defense Attorneys

MyIndianaDefenseLawyer.com

Free Initial Consultation

(888) 632-5650

  • Home
  • Criminal Charges
  • Criminal Court Procedures
  • About/Contact
  • Blog

Supreme Court Rules Fleeing From Police As a “Violent” Crime

June 13, 2011 By dave

The Supreme Court issued a ruling this week in a case out of Indiana. At question was whether fleeing from the police was considered a violent felony and therefore could be used to sentence a defendant under the Armed Career Criminal Act.

According to the Armed Career Criminal Act, a federal law, if someone is convicted for three violent felonies, they are to be subject to a 15 year mandatory minimum prison sentence. The defendant in the case had two prior violent felonies and his third conviction was for fleeing from police on a vehicle.

The Supreme Court ruled, in a 6 to 3 decision, that fleeing from the police in a vehicle did, in fact, constitute a violent felony, subjecting the defendant to the mandatory minimum sentence.

Though the Armed Career Criminal Act is a federal law, several states have similar laws on the books. The infamous Three Strikes laws are another example of cumulative convictions carrying harsher penalties.

In this case the Court’s majority determined that fleeing from the police in a vehicle puts the public and the police at risk. While not all of the justices agreed, the majority opinion stated that for every 100 vehicle pursuits, there are 4 injuries. Justice Scalia said the majority used statistics that had not “been tested in the adversary process” according to the New York Times.

Justices Elena Kagan and Ruth Bader Ginsburg disagreed with the ruling on other grounds, saying that Indiana had two other, more serious offenses under the same statute the defendant was charged under. These included flight from police that created a risk of serious injury. But because the defendant wasn’t charged with these more serious, violent offenses, they determined he should not be penalized for a violent offense.

Regardless, the majority ruling stands.

Automobiles are a potentially dangerous weapon and many criminal laws recognize them as such. Charges like Battery can be elevated to a Class C felony when there is a deadly weapon involved. In cases like this, a car would qualify as that deadly weapon.

This same rationale is used in making the penalties for drunk driving so severe. It’s the risk of hurting or killing someone that makes offenses like this so serious. Even if no injury occurs, you are still penalized for the possibility.

Whether you are charged with drunk driving or battery involving a deadly weapon, a criminal defense attorney can help.

Filed Under: criminal law Tagged With: courts, police

Free Legal Consultation

Contact our attorneys for a free legal case evaluation on any criminal charge by calling:


(888) 632-5650


Receive our free legal defense consultation and case evaluation. We'll explain what you are facing in plain language, and tell you how we can help.

Criminal Charges

  • Battery
  • Criminal Mischief / Computer Tampering
  • Disorderly Conduct
  • Domestic Battery (Assault)
  • Driving on a Suspended License
  • Drug Posession with Intent
  • Drug Possession
  • Drunk Driving (OWI)
  • Drunk Driving / OWI – 2nd Offense
  • Failure to Appear
  • Fraud / Check Deception (Bad Checks) / Identity Theft
  • Harassment / Stalking
  • Hit & Run
  • Intimidation
  • Marijuana Possession
  • Reckless / Aggressive Driving
  • Restraining Order Violations
  • Theft / Shoplifting
  • Weapons Offense
Copyright © 2025 Get Lawyer Leads, Inc.
THIS IS AN ADVERTISEMENT. This is not a law firm or referral service and does not provide legal advice. This is a free matching service only, claim reviews will be performed by a third party attorney. An attorney-client relationship is not formed when you submit the form and you are under no obligation to retain a lawyer who contacts you through this service. Services are not available in all states.